Modern Australian Magazine

University funding debates should be broadened to reflect their democratic purpose

  • Written by Dominic O'Sullivan, Associate Professor of Political Science, Charles Sturt University

In 2017, Murdoch University successfully applied to the Fair Work Commission to terminate its Enterprise Agreement. From the National Tertiary Education Union’s (NTEU) perspective this was an attack on staff salaries and conditions and showed industrial relations law was deeply one-sided.

For university management having the agreement terminated was a legitimate industrial strategy, justified by a need for flexibility and cost containment. The wider trade union movement supported the NTEU perspective. The Murdoch case contributed to the development of a much wider campaign: “Change the Rules”. Changing the rules of industrial relations for better pay, fairer conditions and job security. Reversing the trend towards high rates of casualisation and low wage growth.

But the rules of the game, as far as universities are concerned, are set in a wider context. The context of what universities are for and what they are intended to achieve. While their economic purpose is reasonably clear, contemporary Australian policy debates focus primarily on how and by whom their teaching is funded. This diminishes understanding of universities’ democratic purpose and wider social mission.

What is the university for?

The principal polarising point in the university funding debate is whether demand or central planning should determine the number of people taught. The second is the proportion of the cost that should be met by the state vis-à-vis the student.

Read more: Why our university funding debate wouldn't make sense to Germans

While a proportion of universities’ per student public funding must support research, the funding model’s general assumption is that universities are labour market production lines. Research policy debate is confined to the related ideal of “industry” purchasing university research to reduce the contributions government must make to the cost of university research. Universities have an incentive to see research as simply a fund-raising activity.

These rules need to change in the interests of stronger democracy. Higher education’s current policy focus understates the idea of universities as public institutions serving a public good. Universities have important and essential contributions to make to democracy’s better functioning. The idea that democracy requires an educated population is as old as democracy itself.

University funding debates should be broadened to reflect their democratic purpose Academic freedom is important because evidence and reason matter to the formation of public opinion. Paul Miller/AAP

Research to support economic prosperity is important, but so is research to support public understanding and capacity to contribute to policy debates. Australia’s research Engagement and Impact evaluation policy understates this by measuring engagement principally in terms of the economic value of relationships with research “end users”.

Academic freedom

The university’s most important strength is its intellectual independence, and the academic freedom that assures that independence. Research for government or for industry is not independent. This kind of consultancy work may be legitimate and important, but it ought not compromise the presumption that knowledge cannot fully advance, and the democratic system work as it should, unless research is ideologically independent. It must also be contestable and brought into the public domain for evaluation and debate, and to inform public opinion and decision-making.

There is a public good argument to fund knowledge creation for this democratic purpose, which means academic freedom must be defended at all costs. Yet the University of Melbourne, for example, took steps to weaken that essential characteristic of university research when it proposed removing from its Enterprise Agreement the commitment that its academics would “engage in critical enquiry, intellectual discourse and public controversy without fear or favour”. This suggests an institution willing to compromise its democratic mission.

Read more: As Melbourne University staff strike over academic freedom, it's time to take the issue seriously

Academic freedom is important because evidence and reason matter to the formation of public opinion. They matter to the analysis of “fake news”, to counter-balancing an increasingly partisan Australian private news media at the same time as financial support for the national public broadcaster is being reduced.

Research that is not independent, that is conducted with fear and favour, is unscholarly. It compromises intellectual integrity and ensures knowledge cannot be a public and democratic good. Research for public good and research sold for private benefit can co-exist, but the latter cannot override the public mission of a public institution.

Universities play an essential role in the development of vocational and professional skills for both the individual and the common good. But if this is all they do, if they are not independently and objectively discovering and disseminating new knowledge for the public good, a society is presuming ignorance as a substitute for robust democracy.

University funding debates should be broadened to reflect their democratic purpose In a democracy, university graduates should leave with an understanding of power, where it comes from and why, who has it and why. Mick Tsikas

Understanding power

There is a public good argument for people to graduate from university with a well-developed understanding of power. Where it comes from and why, who has it and why, and how one influences it for society’s betterment. Highly developed critical thinking skills, the ability to write clearly and present well-informed and reasoned arguments are essential to influencing power. They ought not be the skills of an elite who have the money to buy the time to read, think and deliberate.

This is partly an argument for raising the status and availability of a liberal arts education, either on its own or in conjunction with a professional or vocational degree so that the social imperative to ‘be’ something when you grow up is still satisfied: an idea inculcated in children even before they start school.

One may reasonably wish to be a nurse, a teacher or an accountant but one should also expect to be a citizen. A nurse should be able to contribute to health policy debate. A teacher ought to know more than what must be taught this week. An accountant should know the democratic and social context in which business operates.

Authors: Dominic O'Sullivan, Associate Professor of Political Science, Charles Sturt University

Read more http://theconversation.com/university-funding-debates-should-be-broadened-to-reflect-their-democratic-purpose-97075

Australia Today

Yes, this continent was invaded in 1788 – an international law expert explains

Rowan Nicholson, Associate Lecturer and Co-director of the Sydney Centre for International Law, University of Sydney

Should we remember January 26 1788 as “Invasion Day”?The colonisation of Australia was an invasion from an Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander perspective.But critics of the name “Invasion Day” object that it emphasises just one side of the story – that from a Europea...

29,000 cancers overdiagnosed in Australia in a single year

Alexandra Barratt, Professor of Public Health, University of Sydney

Men are 17% more likely to be diagnosed with cancer than they were 30 years ago.fizkes/ShutterstockAlmost one in four cancers detected in men were overdiagnosed in 2012, according to our new research, published today in the Medical Journal of Australia. In the same year, we found that approximately ...

How a year of trying to buy nothing made me a smarter shopper and a better teacher

Ellen Heyting, PhD student in Education and Head of Years 11 and 12, Monash University

Year 7 students at the International School of Helsinki, Finland, doing a sustainable development exercise with the author (top left) and fellow teacher Rachael Thrash.Katja Lehtonen, Author providedIt started as a New Year’s resolution driven by guilt and a touch of sibling rivalry – bu...

10½ commandments of writing

Sean Williams, Lecturer, Flinders University

Things to keep in mind for writers young and old.Kenny Luo/UnsplashEvery author is asked by new writers for advice. There is, however, no all-encompassing, single answer that also happens to be correct. Quite a lot of commonly offered suggestions (“write every day”) don’t work for ...

How smart were our ancestors? Turns out the answer isn't in brain size, but blood flow

Roger S. Seymour, Professor Emeritus of Physiology, University of Adelaide

Skulls hold clues to intelligence. (Clockwise from left: Australopithecus, orangutan, gorilla, chimpanzee)Roger Seymour, Author providedHow did human intelligence evolve? Anthropologists have studied this question for decades by looking at tools found in archaeological digs, evidence of the use of f...

Holidays & Travel

Five things to take when traveling to New Zealand

New Zealand is a sovereign island country located in the southwestern Pacific Ocean region. It is known to be a country of scenery, mountains, waterfalls, caves, beautiful lakes, golden-sanded beaches...

Benefits of hiring a car for your vacation

Car Rentals are an alternative that is being increasingly used by travellers, particularly in the twenty-first century. Small-cost airlines allow us to fly to any city in the world for...

Best Places to Rent a Car in WA

If you are in Western Australia and you are looking to rent a vehicle, whether you are in the area for holiday or you are a resident, it is important...

5 Digital Free Holidays: Take a trek and get back to nature

Our current digital age has connected us to each other and the vast opportunities around the world like no other time in history. And yet, sometimes we need to get...

Places to visit on your first trip to North America

This vast continent, home to one of the biggest countries in the world, is certainly not an easy thing to explore. Its diverse array of cultures and peoples, cities full...

Must-Visit US Destinations for Australians

Australia is a sought-after travel destination for tourists from around the world for its incredible cities, beautiful landscapes, history, culture, and beyond. Tourists flock to Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, the Gold...

5 Reasons For Visiting the Netherlands in Spring

The Netherlands is a stunning part of Europe and according to Markus De Jong, travel expert at adviesjagers.nl Australians love to visit the Netherlands as part of their travels around...

Winter fun in Colorado

Colorado is one of the most visited states in the United States due to the numerous beautiful places evenly distributed in every part of the State. There are lots of...

Essential Personal Hygiene Tips for Traveling

Staying healthy and maintaining good personal hygiene are two of the most important aspects of traveling, but it might not always be easy to achieve. As crucial it is to...

Fashion & Beauty

Most Comfortable Types of Inner-wears

Whether you are a working woman or stay at home mom, the power of comfortable inner-wear is known to every woman. A pair of difficult inner-wear not only can hinder...

Things to Avoid When Applying Mascara

A woman who does not dream of beautiful long eyelashes must have been born with them. Those of us who are less fortunate have a tool that helps us in...

BEST BAGS FOR MEN TO HIT THE DAY WITH SWAG

No matter what walk of life, you belong to. There can be stuff that you have to carry with you as you travel. Whether you are a student, an employee...

ELEGANT DRESSES TO CONSIDER IN 2020

Dressing up for events as well as for work is highly important to women. Looking your best is not a luxury; it is mandatory. For this purpose, we choose various...

Basic Clothing Items Found in Almost Everyone’s Closet

Usually, everyone enjoys a closet crowded with clothes, yet no one has anything to wear when an event shows up. This is more like a ‘global problem’ faced by women...

Differences between chandelier earrings and drop

Earrings have been playing a significant role in embracing the beauty of women for ages. The history of earing shows its importance even from 2500 B.C. with time, and more...

Popular articles from Modern Australian

Losing weight: Find out your BMI7 WAYS TO DECORATE YOUR LIVING ROOM WALLWHY SHOULD YOU INCLUDE SEAFOOD IN YOUR DIETTen best cocktail recipes to enjoy with your friendsCleanliness is the key to have good healthWhat is zinc oxide, and how does it protect your skin from the sun?What are the disadvantages of renovating your homeTips to Brighten Your HomePros and Cons of Waterproof FlooringThings to Avoid When Applying MascaraBEST BAGS FOR MEN TO HIT THE DAY WITH SWAGShowers vs tubs- Which is better?The 10 Unique Restaurant ConceptsELEGANT DRESSES TO CONSIDER IN 2020King Beats Fitness