Modern Australian



What's your beef? How 'carbon labels' can steer us towards environmentally friendly food choices

  • Written by Adrian R. Camilleri, Senior Lecturer in Marketing, University of Technology Sydney

What did you have for dinner last night? Might you have made a different choice if you had a simple way to compare the environmental impacts of different foods?

Most people do not recognise the environmental impact of their food choices. Our research, published in Nature Climate Change, shows that even when consumers do stop to think about the greenhouse gas emissions associated with their food, they tend to underestimate it.

Fortunately, our study also points to a potential solution. We found that a simple “carbon label” can nudge consumers in the right direction, just as nutrition information helps to highlight healthier options.

Read more: How to reduce your kitchen's impact on global warming

Most food production is highly industrialised, and has environmental impacts that most people do not consider. In many parts of the world, conversion of land for beef and agricultural production is a major cause of deforestation. Natural gas is a key input in the manufacture of fertiliser. Refrigeration and transportation also depend heavily on fossil fuels.

Overall, food production contributes 19-29% of global greenhouse emissions. The biggest contributor is meat, particularly red meat. Cattle raised for beef and dairy products are major sources of methane, a potent greenhouse gas.

Meat production is inherently inefficient: fertiliser is used to grow feedstock, but only a small portion of this feed becomes animal protein. It takes about 38 kilograms of plant-based protein to produce 1kg of beef – an efficiency of just 3%. For comparison, pork has 9% efficiency and poultry has 13%.

We could therefore cut greenhouse emissions from food significantly by opting for more vegetarian or vegan meals.

Food for thought

To find out whether consumers appreciate the environmental impact of their food choices, we asked 512 US volunteers to estimate the greenhouse emissions of 19 common foods and 18 typical household appliances.

We told the respondents that a 100-watt incandescent light bulb turned on for 1 hour produces 100 “greenhouse gas emission units”, and asked them to make estimates about the other items using this reference unit. In these terms, a serving of beef produces 2,481 emission units.

As shown below, participants underestimated the true greenhouse gas emissions of foods and appliances in almost every case. For example, the average estimate for a serving of beef was around 130 emission units – more than an order of magnitude less than the true amount. Crucially, foods were much more underestimated than appliances.

What's your beef? How 'carbon labels' can steer us towards environmentally friendly food choices Consumers consistently underestimate the greenhouse emissions of food. Camilleri et al. Nature Climate Change 2018

Improving consumers’ knowledge

People often overestimate their understanding of common everyday objects and processes. You might think you have a pretty solid idea of how a toilet works, until you are asked to describe it in exact detail.

Food is a similarly familiar but complex phenomenon. We eat it every day, but its production and distribution processes are largely hidden. Unlike appliances, which have energy labels, are plugged into an electrical outlet, emit heat, and generally have clear indications of when they are using electricity, the release of greenhouse gases in the production and transportation of food is invisible.

One way to influence food choice is through labelling. We designed a new carbon label to communicate information about the total amount of greenhouse emissions involved in the production and transport of food.

Drawing on knowledge from the design of existing labels for nutrition, fuel economy and energy efficiency, we came up with the label shown below. It has two key features.

First, it translates greenhouse emissions into a concrete, familiar unit: equivalent number of light bulb minutes. A serving of beef and vegetable soup, for example, is roughly equivalent to a light bulb turned on for 2,127 minutes – or almost 36 hours.

Second, it displays the food’s relative environmental impact compared with other food, on an 11-point scale from green (low impact) to red (high impact). Our serving of beef and vegetable soup rates at 10 on the scale – deep into the red zone – because beef production is so emissions-intensive.

What's your beef? How 'carbon labels' can steer us towards environmentally friendly food choices In the can - a carbon label for beef and vegetable soup reveals its high environmental impact.

To test the label, we asked 120 US volunteers to buy cans of soup from a selection of six. Half of the soups contained beef and the other half were vegetarian. Everyone was presented with price and standard nutritional information. Half of the group was also presented with our new carbon labels.

Volunteers who were shown the carbon labels chose significantly fewer beef soup options. Importantly, they also had more accurate perceptions of the relative carbon footprints of the different soups on offer.

Read more: You've heard of a carbon footprint – now it's time to take steps to cut your nitrogen footprint

Figuring out the carbon footprint of every food item is difficult, expensive, and fraught with uncertainty. But we believe a simplified carbon label – perhaps using a traffic light system or showing relative scores for different foods – can help inform and empower consumers to reduce the environmental impact of their food choices.

Authors: Adrian R. Camilleri, Senior Lecturer in Marketing, University of Technology Sydney

Read more http://theconversation.com/whats-your-beef-how-carbon-labels-can-steer-us-towards-environmentally-friendly-food-choices-108424

The Conversation

NEWS

The business of sport - trends in Australia's commercial sports market

Australia has a deserved reputation as a nation of sport lovers. But sport is not just an enjoyable pastime or a way to keep fit. For thousands of Australians, sport...

What's the deal (or no-deal) with Brexit? Here's everything explained

On June 23, 2016 the United Kingdom held a referendum to decide whether it should leave or remain in the European Union. More than 30 million people took part in...

it's too late for the silent generation

Healthy people now in their 50s and 60s will be the first generations to benefit from reform. For people already in care, changes will come too late.from www.shutterstock.comA surprising group...

Why do so few Aussies speak an Australian language?

Linguistically speaking, Australia is special. With around 250 languages spoken when Australia was first colonised, Australia was one of the most linguistically diverse places in the world. But few people...

It's designers who can make gaming more accessible for people living with disabilities

Redressing a tendency to marginalise disability in games requires an awareness of disability at a design level. Humphrey Muleba/Unsplash, CC BYAnyone can play video games, right? If you’ve been following...

Ten ways teacher librarians improve literacy in schools

Australian schools constantly strive to improve the literacy outcomes of their students. Supporting literacy achievement for struggling readers is particularly important because these readers have their disadvantage compounded: capable students...

The financially well-off defy the stereotypes. They include retirees, and mortgagees

Financial well-being isn't always where you expect to find it, in part it depends on attitude.ShutterstockFinancial well-being is hard to get a handle on.That’s because it’s a mix of how...

the power of not being too clear

Specify what you want, and that might be all you'll get, whereas if you are vague...ShutterstockIncentives, in one form or other, are central to our lives.The Soviet experiment ended in...

Penalties for animal cruelty double in SA, but is this enough to stop animal abuse?

Australian states and territories have in the last decade reformed their animal welfare laws.Tim Golder/UnsplashAustralia is a nation of animal lovers, so when animal abuse is reported in the media...

should teaching students who fail a literacy and numeracy test be barred from teaching?

Starting this year, teaching students won't be able to register as teachers unless they pass a literacy and numeracy test.www.shutterstock.comStarting this month, teaching students who fail or haven’t yet taken...

Why Antarctica's sea ice cover is so low (and no, it's not just about climate change)

Sea ice responds to changes in winds and ocean currents, sometimes with origins thousands of kilometres away.NASA/Nathan KurtzSea ice cover in Antarctica shrank rapidly to a record low in late...

How to feed a growing population healthy food without ruining the planet

For many of us, a better diet means eating more fruit and vegetables.iStock, CC BY-NCIf we’re serious about feeding the world’s growing population healthy food, and not ruining the planet...

Popular articles from Modern Australian

Budget Gifting Ideas That Teens Can UtiliseUnforgettable Attractions of Perth  A tour guide to MelbourneAussies Hate Saving Money for a TripTips for Optimising Your Shoulder Surgery Recovery PeriodMistakes You Must Avoid While Purchasing Furniture Do's and Don'ts for Louvre InstallationCreative Ways To Stay Fit In The New YearTop 5 Places to Visit in Australia8 Ways to Fight Inflammation6 Athlete Inspirations For Adopting The Gym LifeHow to Get Your Child Into Modelling: 5 Top Tips for Breaking Into the IndustryThe Best Design Trends for Creating a Restful BedroomBody Talk: Losing Weight and Gaining Good HealthWhy You Need To Get a Forex Trading Education