Modern Australian
The Times

it has something to do with China)

  • Written by Benjamin Reilly, Professor, University of Western Australia

In international affairs, words are bullets, according to an old diplomatic saying. If so, Australia in recent years has begun firing new ammunition.

In his address to the Aspen Security Forum today, Prime Minister Scott Morrison stressed the importance of Australia’s alliances with fellow liberal democracies, the Five Eyes partnership, our “ever‑closer” ties with Europe and our

belief in the values and institutions that the United States has championed.

In a similar address to the Lowy Institute a year ago, Morrison also praised India and Japan as countries with “shared values” to Australia.

And in the press conference at last week’s AUSMIN talks between the Australian and US foreign and defence ministers, there were 15 references to “democratic values” (on the American side), “shared values” (the preferred Australian formulation) and related phrases (“fundamental values”, “value sets”).

“Values”, a word seldom used in the past, has now assumed a central place in our foreign policy rhetoric. Speeches, press conferences and policy statements vibrate with the V-word.

it has something to do with China) The joint statement after the AUSMIN talks stressed the ‘shared security, interests, values, and prosperity’ between the US and Australia. Brendan Smialowski/AP

A counterpoint to China’s value system

The reason for the return of values to our diplomatic rhetoric is no mystery. China’s emergence as the largest and most powerful autocracy in history, with an economic weight to match, has forced Australia to balance its mercantile and security interests.

Over the past decade, Australia allowed itself to become economically dependent on China, which takes a third of all our exports and over 80% of key commodities like iron ore.

As our economic dependency increased, China also changed, becoming more repressive domestically and more aggressive in the international sphere.

China’s own governance model is based on a different set of values, which prioritise allegiance to the state and party and involve restrictions antithetical to open societies. These include limits on freedom of speech, association, religion and anything else that could enable collective action in opposition to the state.

As it has championed this model around the world, Beijing has increasingly targeted democracies like Australia with local influence operations, political interference and, most recently, its crude “wolf-warrior diplomacy”.

Read more: Behind China's newly aggressive diplomacy: 'wolf warriors' ready to fight back

Australia’s new embrace of the term “values” has also been accompanied by much more hawkish words on China.

While Australia has declined to join the US in more aggressive freedom of navigation campaigns in the South China Sea, the AUSMIN joint statement criticised China’s behaviour in the disputed waters, as well as in Hong Kong and Xinjiang. Also consistent with democratic values, it backed Taiwan’s membership or observer status in international bodies.

The term ‘values’ used to risk push-back

Until recently, Australian leaders ignored or downplayed the role of values in our foreign policy, preferring to focus on economic issues and engagement with Asia.

Talk of “democratic values” risked push-back from other nations in the region. Former Malaysia Prime Minister Mohamed Mahathir and Singapore’s long-time leader, Lee Kuan Yew, for example, were advocates for the idea of “Asian values”, which was more culturally specific to their countries.

They argued that individual freedom was a Western ideal, not compatible with Asian societies.

Successive Australian governments, keen to engage more with the region but still wary of being too close to Asia, largely accepted this.

The Howard government, in particular, was often at pains to frame Australia as a European society that approached Asia as an outsider, as academic John Fitzgerald put it:

Australia had one set of values, Asians another, and all parties should respect the values associated with the other’s ethno-cultural traditions by remaining silent on values altogether.

it has something to do with China) John Howard and Singapore’s Lee Kuan Yew agreed to disagree when it came to their respective value systems. Alan Porritt/AAP

How our diplomatic language has evolved

The shift in our diplomatic language began a decade ago with the idea of a “rules-based order”. This term (like values) had hardly been used in official policy before, up to and including the Howard government.

It began to gather a lexical head of steam under the Rudd and Gillard governments, and reached its pinnacle in the 2016 Defence White Paper, in which “rules-based global order” appeared no less than 48 times and was identified as one of Australia’s core strategic interests.

The ascent of “values” has followed a similar trajectory. It was mentioned seven times in the 2016 Defence White Paper, including specific references to “shared democratic values” with the US, India, Japan and New Zealand.

“Values” then went mainstream in the 2017 Foreign Policy White Paper, with no less than 31 references, including a whole section devoted to “Australia’s values”.

Democracy and multiculturalism were identified as our two core values, staking big claims for Australian exceptionalism:

We are one of the oldest democracies and the most successful multicultural society in the world.

it has something to do with China) Morrison stressed Australia’s ‘shared values of democracy’ with India following a virtual summit with Narendra Modi in June. Lukas Coch/AAP

Talk of values must be met with action

This language provides an obvious connection with the US. And the contrast with China could not be more stark.

With China’s rise under President Xi Jinping, different value systems now underpin different visions of security. By pushing democratic societies to confront this reality, Xi has done us a favour.

Australia has reaffirmed its core belief in a rules-based international order linked to democratic values and strengthened its partnership with other like-minded nations, such as India, Japan and the US.

Read more: Payne and Reynolds leave Washington with key 'wins' — and room to disagree with US on China

However, the language of values also presents challenges to other aspects of our foreign policy.

It is difficult to square the focus on values with our treatment of asylum seekers, selective application of international law and ongoing engagement with autocratic regimes in Asia. (A good example of all three is the now-lapsed refugee resettlement deal with Cambodia’s brutal Hun Sen regime, signed with a champagne toast, which Morrison presided over when he was immigration minister.)

If values are now the coin of our foreign policy realm, we will have to start walking the talk.

Authors: Benjamin Reilly, Professor, University of Western Australia

Read more https://theconversation.com/why-is-values-the-new-buzzword-in-australian-foreign-policy-hint-it-has-something-to-do-with-china-143839

10 Benefits of Choosing Professional Tutoring Penrith Services

Every student has unique learning strengths, challenges, and academic goals. While classroom teaching provides essential knowledge and structure, so...

Sunshine Coast Baby Classes Prove Big Hit Among First-Time Mums

There's a movement gaining traction on the Sunshine Coast, providing a village of support, socialisation and relief for first-time mothers and babie...

Father's Day Gift Ideas for Men Who Are Hard to Buy For

Some dads are easy to buy for. Others do not want anything, already have everything, or give you the classic "don't worry about me" answer every yea...

Top 5 Mistakes That Wear Out Your Brakes Faster

Brakes don't need frequent replacements like oil changes do.   But a lot of the wear happens quietly, over months, because of habits most drivers...

Plantation Shutters vs Curtains: Which Is Better for Your New Home?

Moving into a new home is an exciting opportunity to personalise your space and make it your own. While many homeowners focus on furniture, flooring...

Celebration of Life vs Traditional Funeral: What's the Difference?

When saying goodbye to someone you love, there is no single way to honour their life. Every family has different traditions, beliefs, and preference...

Building Approval for Roofing Projects: What Homeowners Need to Know

Roofing projects are an important part of maintaining and protecting your home. Whether you're repairing storm damage, replacing an ageing roof, or ...

Chatswood Tutoring And Its Role In Academic Achievement

Academic success often requires more than classroom attendance alone. Students face increasing expectations as they progress through school, particu...

Why Laser Hair Removal Treatments Continue Growing In Popularity

Managing unwanted hair can become time-consuming and frustrating for many people, especially when shaving, waxing, and other temporary methods requi...

Choosing the Right Devices for a Flexible Workplace

For IT leaders managing large fleets, the device layer is where workforce productivity and security policy meet. The shift towards flexible and hybrid...

How Business Advisory Services Help Companies Achieve Sustainable Growth

Every business owner aims to build a profitable and sustainable organisation. While dedication, innovation, and hard work are important, achieving l...

Why Body Contouring Has Become A Popular Cosmetic Treatment

Many people maintain healthy lifestyles through regular exercise and balanced eating habits but still struggle with stubborn areas of fat that are d...

How to Choose the Right POS Hardware for Your Business in Australia

A lot of Australian business owners spend weeks researching POS software but buy hardware almost as an afterthought. That's a mistake. The wrong har...

Why Material Handling Hose Is Critical for Industrial Efficiency

A high-performance material handling hose is an essential component in industries that transport abrasive, dry, or bulk materials on a daily basis...

How to Choose the Right Lawyer in Melbourne for Your Situation

Choosing legal support can feel difficult, especially when the stakes are personal or business-related. The right lawyer in Melbourne should underst...

Hoteliers Look to Clever Value Adds to Increase Revenue

The Australian hospitality industry is still in recovery mode after a notoriously rough patch in recent years. While there has been a post-COVID tra...

Moving to Queensland? Here’s How to Prep Your Car for the Big Move North

There’s no sign of the northern migration slowing down, with thousands of southerners fleeing from chaotic lifestyles and cooler climates for a brig...

Diesel Shortage to Impact Trades and Contractors

Strait of Hormuz blockage affecting all major parts of trades and construction Trades and construction across residential, commercial and industria...