Modern Australian
The Times

How FTX Australia was able to get away with claiming it was 'ASIC-licenced'

  • Written by Pamela Hanrahan, Professor of Commercial Law and Regulation, UNSW Business School, UNSW Sydney
How FTX Australia was able to get away with claiming it was 'ASIC-licenced'

When cryptocurrency exchange FTX Group collapsed in the Bahamas last month, its local subsidiaries FTX Australia Pty Ltd and FTX Express Pty Ltd fell over too.

The Australian companies were placed into administration on November 11 and within days the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) had suspended the Australian financial service licence FTX Australia had held since March 2022.

The fact that FTX Australia had an Australian financial service came as a surprise to some people, who had wrongly assumed everything crypto-related was beyond the reach of Australia’s regulators.

It also raised questions – including for Assistant Treasurer Stephen Jones – about how FTX Australia managed to acquire its Australian financial services licence, and how ASIC seemed to have missed the chance to intervene sooner.

And it draws wider attention to the 20-year-old licensing system and what an Australian financial service actually means for the firms that have them.

Licensed to do what, precisely?

FTX Trading Limited When FTX commenced operations in Australia this year, its media release was headed: “FTX launches fully registered and licensed Australian operations”. But what exactly was it licensed to do? The Australian financial service (AFS) licensing regime in place since the late 1990s authorises each firm to do specified things, in relation to specified financial products, for specified clients. Each firm’s licence is different, and what is required by ASIC is different depending on what the firm is authorised to do. FTX Australia’s licence authorised it to deal in, make a market for, and provide general advice relating to derivatives and foreign exchange contracts to retail and wholesale clients. That’s it. Note that crypto-assets are not specified, nor is running a crypto-asset exchange. The jury is still out globally on whether crypto-assets (as distinct from investments derived from crypto-assets) are financial products at all. It is possible to think of them as like gold bullion or fine art – or pet rocks – where the asset itself is not a financial product, but a financial product might be constructed from it. If a cryptocurrency is not a financial product, then licensing laws can’t apply, which might explain why one of the two firms set up in Australia – FTX Express, which operated the crypto-exchange – was not AFS licensed. Read more: 'I thought crypto exchanges were safe': the lesson in FTX's collapse The lesson is that knowing a firm has an AFS licence only takes you so far, and often not very far at all. Unless you check the specific authorisations, there’s no way of knowing how little the firm you are dealing with is licensed to do. And ASIC-regulation doesn’t involve prudential regulation, which is directed at the stability of the company itself, ensuring among other things that it should be able to meet its financial commitments under reasonable circumstances. Prudential regulation is the job of the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority, which regulated neither FTX Australia nor FTX Express. Licences for sale FTX Australia’s ASIC licence was originally granted to someone else entirely back in 2008. A series of takeovers meant it passed through a number of hands until it ended up with FTX in March this year. While an original applicant has to satisfy rigorous checks, this hasn’t always been the case for subsequent purchasers. ASIC has known for years that its ASF licences were ending up in new hands when companies were bought and sold. In 2017, it asked the government’s ASIC Enforcement Review Taskforce to recommend changes to the law that would allow it to revisit an AFS licence when its owners changed. The change that was eventually legislated in 2020 only required licensees to notify ASIC when a licence changed hands, within 30 days. It did not require ASIC to approve the change in control. Limited ASIC powers ASIC is able to inquire further to determine whether there is reason to believe a new licensee was likely to contravene its statutory obligations or is “fit and proper” – but it is not required to do so. If it finds either that the licensee is likely to contravene its obligations or that it is not fit and proper, it is able to suspend or cancel the licence after giving the new owners a fair hearing. Read more: How 'bad credit' lender Cigno has dodged ASIC's grasp But such inquiries have not become routine. Most of the (hundreds of) licensee purchases notified each year seem to go through to the keeper, as did FTX’s. Even if ASIC had reviewed FTX’s purchase of the licence in March 2022, it might well have found no grounds to revoke it, given the very limited range of activities it authorised. The FTX collapse may result in ASIC changing its attitude to change-of-control transactions involving AFS licensees, for which it might need more resources. But even if that happens, clients would still be well advised to take care to understand exactly what “AFS licensed” really means. Authors: Pamela Hanrahan, Professor of Commercial Law and Regulation, UNSW Business School, UNSW Sydney

Read more https://theconversation.com/how-ftx-australia-was-able-to-get-away-with-claiming-it-was-asic-licenced-196361

Road Signs: Understanding Their Role in Clear and Effective Signage

Effective signage and display hardware can help businesses communicate information, promote products and organise customer or visitor movement. Road...

Bottle Label Printing: Key Factors to Consider Before Your Next Packaging Run

Effective packaging begins with understanding the product, bottle material, artwork and production requirements when planning bottle label printing. H...

Planning a Long-Distance Move With Interstate Movers Melbourne

Moving between states involves more planning than a typical local relocation. Along with packing and transporting household belongings, you need to...

Understanding the Role of an I/O Controller in Industrial Automation

Modern industrial systems depend on accurate communication between sensors, machines and control systems. An I/O controller can help manage this commu...

How the Right Mining Hose Supports Demanding Operations

Mining environments place considerable demands on equipment used for material transfer, water management and processing. Hoses operating in these co...

Simple Ideas for Making Social Gatherings More Memorable

We have all been to those parties where everyone just stands around the kitchen island, staring at their phones, waiting for someone else to make a mo...

Outdoor Wall Lights: Improving Exterior Lighting Around Your Home

Lighting can influence how a room looks, feels and functions, so the right fitting should be selected according to both appearance and practical req...

Commercial Office Cleaning: Combining Routine Office Cleaning With Melbourne Service

Keeping a workplace clean requires a service that can accommodate everyday tasks as well as the particular needs of the business. Professional comme...

Caravan Sales in Queensland: How to Find the Right Caravan for Sale QLD

Caravan ownership is about more than having somewhere to sleep while travelling. For many Queenslanders, it is one of the best ways to explore regio...

What Sir Walter Buffalo Turf Actually Costs in 2026 (And Why Quotes Vary So Much)

Two quotes landed on a Hills District homeowner's kitchen table last spring for the exact same 80-square-metre backyard. One said $12 a metre. The o...

Nearly 1,300 NSW Hospital Beds Are Occupied By People Who Are Ready To Go Home

1,276 people in NSW hospitals have been medically cleared for discharge but remain in hospital because they're still waiting for NDIS or aged care sup...

National Survey Launched to Measure Operational Impacts of Federal NDIS Policy Reforms

The effects of recent NDIS reforms are beginning to move beyond policy papers and into day to day service delivery. A new national survey is asking ...

Beyond the Nappy Cake: Baby Shower Gifts That Get Used

What new Australian parents unwrap, keep, and quietly thank you for months later. Six weeks after my daughter was born, I did an audit of the baby sh...

Parent-Advocates Are Reshaping Frontline Disability Service Delivery

Parents have always been part of the disability sector. They advocate, coordinate services, challenge decisions and often become the person holding ev...

Vista Cruises Enters "Two-Flagship Era" as Vista Aurora Completes Inaugural Voyage

Vista Aurora Sets Sail along the Yangtze. (Photo courtesy of the company)YICHANG, China — August 5, 2026 — Vista Aurora, a high-end interprovinc...

A Digital Preparation Checklist For International Medical Conferences

An international medical conference compresses many responsibilities into a few days. A delegate may need to present research, move between venues, ...

The Growing Popularity of Lab Grown Diamonds in Sydney and Hong Kong

The diamond industry has changed significantly in recent years as more buyers seek ethical, affordable, and sustainable alternatives to mined diamon...

Modern AI SEO Agency vs Traditional SEO: What’s the Difference

Search engine optimisation has changed dramatically over the past few years. Search engines have become smarter, user behaviour has evolved, and bus...