Modern Australian
The Times

Australia claims it is ‘on track’ to save nature. We disagree

  • Written by Paul Allan Elton, Doctoral researcher, Australian National University

Without fanfare, the Australian government has published the latest snapshot on its progress toward halting and reversing the loss of Australia’s biodiversity – our unique wildlife, plants and nature – by 2030. This report on Australia’s progress under the Global Biodiversity Framework is a self-assessment, and the Australian government has given itself a glowing report card.

We examined the claims in this report, called the Seventh Report to the UN’s Convention on Biological Diversity. And we found the government has been unjustifiably optimistic, rewarding itself for “intentions” and promises so it can claim we are on track.

This is wrong. Ecosystems are being left to degrade, rare and precious species are sliding toward extinction, and billions of dollars are being used to quietly fund subsidies, including for fossil fuels, which contribute to the very destruction the government claims to be fixing.

Our last national report into Australia’s State of the Environment found the condition of the environment was poor and deteriorating. It is more pressing than ever the government drops the spin and gets on with the hard work of addressing the existential threat of biodiversity loss.

Here are four key targets in the report that expose the real story:

1. Restoration: not enough done, and the report knows it

Target 2 of the Global Biodiversity Framework, which calls for the restoration of degraded ecosystems, is one of only two targets the report rates below “on track”. The target requires at least 30% of degraded ecosystems to be under effective restoration by 2030. The report does not even quantify how much Australia is falling behind this target. This is a significant omission: data and modelling tools exist to estimate the extent of degraded ecosystems across Australia, and independent research has done exactly that.

The government also says it is spending hundreds of millions on restoration. But independent research puts the annual cost of restoring Australia’s terrestrial, freshwater and coastal ecosystems in the billions.

Australia claims it is ‘on track’ to save nature. We disagree
There are many different ecosystems in Australia, including these mountains In Tasmania. Matt Palmer/Unsplash, CC BY

2. Protected areas: national figures mask failures

The report claims Australia is “on track” to meet Target 3, or the 30 by 30 target, which aims to protect 30% of Australia’s land by the end of the decade. It states 25% of land and 52% of ocean are under some form of protection. But these figures are seriously misleading.

The framework does not just require 30% protection measured nationally. The protected area system is also supposed to be ecologically representative and “well-connected”, not simply a national land area target.

Australia’s marine protected areas illustrate this issue perfectly. While 52% of Australia’s ocean is formally protected, only 24% is zoned for high protection. Many marine ecosystems remain inadequately represented, for example temperate rocky reefs and kelp forests along the Great Southern Reef.

In 2018, the Commonwealth systematically downgraded marine park protections, reducing the extent of highly protected “no-take” fishing zones and reopening areas to commercial fishing. The more recent shift to a 30% highly protected marine target is welcome, but it reframes the goal without ensuring a variety of marine environments are included.

3. Threatened species: declining, not recovering

Australia is on track to prevent new extinctions under Target 4, the report claims. This is largely anchored in the fact no species are known to have become extinct since the 2022 “no new extinctions” commitment. This is a weak basis for the rating.

Australia already holds the world’s worst record for modern mammal extinctions – 38 species lost since colonisation, more than any other country. Against that grim inheritance, having no further extinctions (that we know about) is a remarkably low bar.

4. Harmful fossil fuel subsidies hidden, conservation spending inflated

Target 18 requires nations to identify subsidies harmful to biodiversity by 2025. The Australian government’s response? It explicitly excludes fossil fuel subsidies from its assessment, and identifies roughly $1.1 billion across agricultural and fisheries categories.

For the first time, research published this year, identified 36 federal subsidies worth $26.3 billion annually that are potentially harmful to biodiversity. Fossil fuel subsidies alone account for $14.1 billion. It is extraordinary the Australian Government believes it can exclude fossil fuel subsidies on the basis of a technicality. Meanwhile, independent estimates place federal biodiversity conservation spending at below $1 billion annually.

The arithmetic is stark: the government spent more than $26 billion a year on harming nature, less than $1 billion conserving it. No government serious about halting biodiversity loss would preside over such an imbalance and say they were “on track”.

Australia claims it is ‘on track’ to save nature. We disagree
Protesters paddle out in a coal export protest in Newcastle in 2024. Recent research found state and federal subsidies for coal, gas and oil products increased 10% in the past year. Michael Gorton

Australians deserve an honest account

Serious weaknesses have previously been identified in Australia’s 2022 Strategy for Nature. It is full of vague intentions without clearly defined targets, accountability, timelines and measures of progress. A promised implementation plan is also still missing, more than three years later.

This new report confirms those weaknesses extend to Australia’s self-assessment, which lacks the rigour and ambition the nature crisis demands.

The reforms of Australia’s nature laws, passed in late 2025, are the most significant in a generation, and we welcome them. But legislation without implementation, adequate funding or a delivery plan is not enough.

This important report – with its hidden subsidies, inflated spending figures, missing implementation plan, and a definition of “on track” that mistakes promises for progress – is not worthy of a nation with both the means and the obligation to lead.

Authors: Paul Allan Elton, Doctoral researcher, Australian National University

Read more https://theconversation.com/australia-claims-it-is-on-track-to-save-nature-we-disagree-278081

Chatswood Tutoring And Its Role In Academic Achievement

Academic success often requires more than classroom attendance alone. Students face increasing expectations as they progress through school, particu...

Why Laser Hair Removal Treatments Continue Growing In Popularity

Managing unwanted hair can become time-consuming and frustrating for many people, especially when shaving, waxing, and other temporary methods requi...

Choosing the Right Devices for a Flexible Workplace

For IT leaders managing large fleets, the device layer is where workforce productivity and security policy meet. The shift towards flexible and hybrid...

How Business Advisory Services Help Companies Achieve Sustainable Growth

Every business owner aims to build a profitable and sustainable organisation. While dedication, innovation, and hard work are important, achieving l...

Why Body Contouring Has Become A Popular Cosmetic Treatment

Many people maintain healthy lifestyles through regular exercise and balanced eating habits but still struggle with stubborn areas of fat that are dif...

How to Choose the Right POS Hardware for Your Business in Australia

A lot of Australian business owners spend weeks researching POS software but buy hardware almost as an afterthought. That's a mistake. The wrong har...

Why Material Handling Hose Is Critical for Industrial Efficiency

A high-performance material handling hose is an essential component in industries that transport abrasive, dry, or bulk materials on a daily basis...

How to Choose the Right Lawyer in Melbourne for Your Situation

Choosing legal support can feel difficult, especially when the stakes are personal or business-related. The right lawyer in Melbourne should underst...

Hoteliers Look to Clever Value Adds to Increase Revenue

The Australian hospitality industry is still in recovery mode after a notoriously rough patch in recent years. While there has been a post-COVID tra...

Moving to Queensland? Here’s How to Prep Your Car for the Big Move North

There’s no sign of the northern migration slowing down, with thousands of southerners fleeing from chaotic lifestyles and cooler climates for a brig...

Diesel Shortage to Impact Trades and Contractors

Strait of Hormuz blockage affecting all major parts of trades and construction Trades and construction across residential, commercial and industria...

Why Holiday Home Owners Turn to Rental Management Agents

The Allure — and the Reality — of Renting Out Your Property Owning a holiday home is a dream for many Australians. Whether it's a beachside sha...

Why Finding Reliable Doctors In Bundoora Is Important For Long-Term Health

Access to quality healthcare plays an important role in maintaining overall wellbeing and managing health concerns early. Trusted Doctors in Bundoor...

Understanding the Different Types of Car Services: Minor vs Major

When it comes to car maintenance, one of the most important things every vehicle owner should understand is the difference between a minor and a maj...

How Superannuation and TPD Insurance Work Together

Superannuation is an essential part of financial planning in Australia. It is designed to provide individuals with income during retirement, helping...

Tiny Towns funding granted for Mt Hotham and Mt Buller upgrades

Alpine Resorts Victoria (ARV) has welcomed funding support from the Victorian Government’s  Tiny Towns Fund, with both Mt Hotham and Mt Buller se...

Locksmith Services: Why Professional Security Solutions Matter More Than Ever

Security is a critical concern for homeowners, businesses, and vehicle owners alike. Whether it involves protecting a property, replacing damaged lo...

Why Tooth Fillings Are Important For Protecting Damaged Teeth

Cavities and minor tooth damage are common dental problems that can worsen if left untreated. Professional tooth fillings help restore damaged teeth, ...