Modern Australian

Is slowing Australia's population growth really the best way out of this crisis?

  • Written by Gabriela D'Souza, Affiliate, Monash department of business statistics and econometrics, Monash University

After weeks of pressuring the government to do more to support temporary migrants who fall outside the criteria for government support, the opposition took a surprising stance in The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald on Sunday.

Labor immigration spokesperson Kristina Keneally called for a rethink of our migration program and asked:

when we restart our migration program, do we want migrants to return to Australia in the same numbers and in the same composition as before the crisis?

She said Australia’s answer should be “no”.

To me, as an economist, the answer should be a resounding “yes”.

Keneally’s piece covered a lot of ground – in addition to making claims about whether or not permanent migrants take the jobs of local workers (they don’t) she broached the topic of reconsidering our temporary migration intake and held open the possibility of further lowering our permanent intake.

Migration is a complex often convoluted area of policy

Temporary migrants can’t just turn up

Ms Keneally’s comments imply that coming to Australia as a temporary migrant is easy.

As the following (rather complex) flowchart indicates, it is anything but.

Is slowing Australia's population growth really the best way out of this crisis? Ball, J 2019 Improving the current system, Effects of Temporary Migration, CEDA report Temporary migration is uncapped: there are no in-principle limits on the number of temporary migrants who can come here. This is by design, so the program can meet the skill needs of our economy at any given time. However, the government has a number of tools it uses to contain the program and target the right skills. Keneally makes the point that the arrival of migrants has made it easier for businesses to ignore local talent. But there are requirements that Australian businesses to tap into the Australian labour market before hiring from overseas. Read more: The government is right – immigration helps us rather than harms us She is right when she says unions and employers and the government should come together to identify looming skill shortages and deliver training and reskilling opportunities to Australian workers so they can fill Australian jobs. But no matter how good our foresight and our education and training systems, we will always have needs for external expertise in areas of emerging importance. Training local workers for projects that suddenly become important can take years, during which those projects would stall. Permanent migrants don’t take Australian’s jobs Keneally says Australia’s migration program has “hurt many Australian workers, contributing to unemployment, underemployment and low wage growth”. Australian research finds this to be untrue. Research I conducted for the Committee for the Economic Development of Australia updating research coducted by Robert Breunig, Nathan Deutscher and Hang Thi To for the Productivity Commission found that the impact of recent migrants (post 1996) on the employment prospects of Australian-born workers was close to zero. If anything, the impact on wages and labour force participation of locals was positive. Flexibility gives us an edge Australia’s migration program is the envy of other countries. Indeed, its success has prompted Britain to consider changing its system to an Australian skills-based system assessed through points. Temporary migration is certain to look very different over the next few years than it has over past few. That’s its purpose – to adapt to changing circumstances. Read more: Blaming immigrants for unemployment, lower wages and high house prices is too simplistic It is difficult to see how a sustained cut in temporary arrivals could assist our recovery. The bridge to the other side of this downturn will depend on migration. It will depend on us continuing to welcome migrants.

Authors: Gabriela D'Souza, Affiliate, Monash department of business statistics and econometrics, Monash University

Read more https://theconversation.com/is-slowing-australias-population-growth-really-the-best-way-out-of-this-crisis-137779

NEWS

UN report says up to 850,000 animal viruses could be caught by humans, unless we protect nature

Shutterstock Human damage to biodiversity is leading us into a pandemic era. The virus that causes COVID-19, for example, is linked to similar viruses in bats, which may have been...

The reputation of Australia’s special forces is beyond repair — it's time for them to be disbanded

Australian Department of DefenceFour years into a constant stream of misconduct allegations, it’s hard to know how to process the latest revelations about the actions of Australia’s special forces in...

Alice Pung — how reading changed my life

Annie Spratt/UnsplashHaving survived starvation and been spared execution, my father arrived in this new country, vassal-eyed and sunken-cheeked. I was born less than a month later and he named me...

From scary pumpkins to bridal bling, how masks are becoming a normal part of our lives in Australia

www.shutterstock.comOn Halloween this Saturday, it won’t be just trick-or-treating children who are wearing spooky costumes. Adults handing out sweet treats may also be sporting Halloween-themed face masks, which are now...

we'll never cut unemployment to 0%, but less than 4% should be our goal

ShutterstockOne of the most concerning things that happens in any recession is the spike in unemployment. The COVID-19-induced recession in Australia and around the world is no exception – other...

Aged care isn't working, but we can create neighbourhoods to support healthy ageing in place

Image: Kathleen Brasher, Author providedThis article is part of our series on aged care. You can read the other articles in the series here.In 2020, the coronavirus pandemic has exposed...

COVID-19 slashed health-care use by more than one-third across the globe. But the news isn't all bad

ShutterstockIt’s no secret the COVID-19 pandemic has changed many aspects of our lives. One is how often we access health care.We’ve conducted what we believe is the first systematic review...

education research should answer to the same standards as medicine

ShutterstockAustralia has one of the highest-quality systems of medical research in the world. It has helped underpin the high standing of Australia’s health system — it’s ranked as one...

As Melbourne's Christmas arrives early, Queensland's election will test whether COVID is a vaccine for incumbents

Anticipating reactions to political attacks can be a tricky business.When Scott Morrison spectacularly trashed the reputation of Australia Post CEO Christine Holgate over her now-notorious gift of Cartier watches to...

Colourful opal fossils point to a diverse group of giant dinosaurs that shared Australia's terrain

North-central New South Wales today is known for its arid, drought-prone climate. During the Cretaceous period, however, it was a lush coastal floodplain with a high diversity of vertebrates including...

Genome and satellite technology reveal recovery rates and impacts of climate change on southern right whales

University of Auckland tohorā research team, Department of Conservation permit DJIAfter close to a decade of globe-spanning effort, the genome of the southern right whale has been released this week...

We put forward a way to govern ASIC better. The government said no

The current governance/management crisis at the Australian Securities and Investments Commission, ASIC has seen a deputy chairman resign and the chairman step aside under a cloud.It might have arisen simply...



News Co Media Group

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion













Popular articles from Modern Australian

These Countries Have the Best Netflix Catalogs4 Ways to Boost Your Games Winnings with BonusesThink You Know Classic Solitaire Inside out? Here Are Some Interesting Facts You’ve Probably Never Heard of4 Memorable Places to Visit in IndiaGoogle's New Pixel 5 is 5G Ready, but is it Good for Gamers?Mistakes To Avoid When Choosing Your Tasmanian Vacation AccommodationBonus Codes for Online PokiesParental Responsibility and Rights When Handling Custody MattersSix Things You Should Never Do During DivorceShipping Container Homes Made From BlocksNHL's Best and Brightest All You Need To Know About The Hyundai i45 For SaleThe Most Popular Cosmetic Surgery Procedures to Look Out for in 2021Tadalafil vs. Vardenafil: Which Is Better?Benefits of sleep for a healthier life