Modern Australian
Men's Weekly

.

Is that the Coalition debt truck parked just past the election?

  • Written by Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

It was a small thing but a revealing moment during Scott Morrison’s Wednesday interview on Nine’s Today show.

Presenter Karl Stefanovic noticed Morrison seemed out of sorts, despite the government having delivered the night before a benign budget that was well received and likely to be popular.

“It is a very big budget. Josh Frydenberg had a very big smile on his face this morning. I thought you might be happier this morning, PM. Everything OK?” Stefanovic asked.

Morrison said he was “fine”. He went on: “I’ve got to tell you, Karl, the reason is this.

"I know, look, budgets are big events and that’s all fine, but I just know the fight we’re in – and the fight we’re in, and me as prime minister I’m in, is to be protecting Australians at this incredibly difficult time.

"I am very cognisant of how big those challenges are. It is with me every second of every day.”

There are a few points to be made here.

Read more: Frydenberg spends the budget bounty to drive unemployment down to new lows

First, the government is using the budget to talk up the current threat of the pandemic to an extent it hadn’t been recently.

Morrison, in particular, had previously been anxious to emphasise the return to as much normality as possible. Now it’s more about lurking dangers.

These provide a justification for the government’s mega spending in the budget. (“Did anyone miss out? Perhaps only the beekeepers of Australia,” quipped one cynical Liberal backbencher.)

The language also indicates Morrison wants to do what state and territory leaders have done – use the pandemic to pave the path to electoral victory.

The other point highlighted by the Today exchange is that Morrison was looking somewhat ragged.

This was accentuated by the contrast with Treasurer Josh Frydenberg who, on the face of it, would have been under the greater stress.

Frydenberg’s performances in the week of his third budget were smooth and, whatever nerves he felt, he appeared unfazed.

The week reinforced the impression he is in the box seat eventually to reach the prime ministership (assuming the Coalition lasts in government).

Pre-budget, he and wife Amie were out for the cameras on a Sunday charity run in Canberra. Post-budget, his staff rang around backbenchers to ask if they’d like a picture with the treasurer.

In question time, Morrison found old problems returning to irritate him. He was pressed on the two internal inquiries into who in his office knew or did what in relation to the Brittany Higgins matter, and he had to say neither was concluded (one had been on hold before this week while the police dealt with their investigation of her rape allegation). Whatever the results of these inquiries, Morrison needs to get them cleared away as soon as possible. They are “barnacles”.

Morrison has been travelling a lot recently and may be tired (although those around him say he’s energised by being on the road). Or he may not be used to sharing the limelight. Or the endless round of everything may be just taking its toll.

Then there’s the challenge of explaining this Labor-lite budget to the hardliners in the Liberal base and among the right-wing commentariat.

The budget has made the opposition’s already formidable task of carving out room for itself more difficult, but it is also proving a hard swallow for those rusted on to the Coalition’s old “debt and deficit” preoccupation.

Read more: View from The Hill: Frydenberg finds the money tree

Many of these critics will be reluctant to buy the proposition the big spending must continue because the pandemic is a constant threat, given they’ve thought the threat was exaggerated in the first place.

The government could attempt to deal with these critics by saying it will “snap back” into tackling debt and deficit as quickly as possible.

But facing an election soon, it doesn’t want to do this, for obvious reasons.

In the budget the timing of the next stage, fiscal consolidation, is imprecise.

The budget papers say: “Progress on the economic recovery will be reviewed at each Budget update. This phase of the Strategy will remain in place until the economic recovery is secure and the unemployment rate is back to pre-crisis levels or lower.”

While some commentary is focused on how the Coalition has done a dramatic U-turn from its old debt-and-deficit rhetoric, there’s an opportunity for Labor to run a major scare campaign claiming it’s not a U-turn at all – that the debt truck is just in the parking lot.

Remember, it can say, when Tony Abbott promised no cuts to health, education and even the ABC – and recall what happened. This time, so the argument runs, cuts and savings will be Coalition priorities again as soon as it has secured the votes.

Morrison and Frydenberg this week have been invoking John Howard’s advice, given to Frydenberg in the early days of the pandemic, that “in times of crisis there are no ideological constraints”.

The question is whether the Liberals have softened their ideology, or just put it in storage during the crisis.

While there can be no definite answer, Tim Colebatch, writing in Inside Story. makes a strong case that the Coalition “won’t dump its political tactic of branding itself as the ‘fiscally responsible’ party and Labor as the party standing for deficits. This [budget] is a short-term tack that will be reversed after the election.

"Of course no government promising $503 billion of deficits in five years can be called fiscally responsible, so it will make cuts then to reclaim the brand,” Colebatch says.

Morrison and Frydenberg are both pragmatists rather than ideologues. But opinions in the wider party are also relevant, as Malcolm Turnbull found on the climate issue.

Frydenberg has pledged there will not be “any sharp pivots towards ‘austerity’”.

Nevertheless, there must be a budgetary reset at some point. And whether a pivot is sharp or not, and what amounts to “austerity” depend in part on whether you are one of the losers.

Read more: Politics with Michelle Grattan: Simon Birmingham and Jim Chalmers on a big spending budget

Authors: Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Read more https://theconversation.com/grattan-on-friday-is-that-the-coalition-debt-truck-parked-just-past-the-election-160877

The Most Common Conveyor System Issues in Manufacturing

In modern manufacturing, conveyor systems play a central role in keeping production lines efficient, consistent, and cost-effective. When they operate...

How to Secure a Long-Term Rental in a Competitive Market

The rental market can be unpredictable and may present challenges if you’re not prepared. Initially, you might submit numerous applications and stil...

What Smart Investors Know About Real Estate

Many people think investing in property is just about buying a house and waiting for it to get expensive. While that can happen, the people who actual...

The Benefits of Seeking Help for Anxiety and Stress

Anxiety and stress have become common experiences in today’s fast-paced world, affecting people across all ages and lifestyles. From work pressures ...

How to Make the Most of Fashion Wholesale Options for Your Brand

If you want to grow a fashion brand without constantly reinventing the wheel, wholesale can be one of the smartest ways to scale. The key is knowing h...

How to Add Value to Your Home Before Selling

Selling a home is not just about putting up a sign and waiting for offers. It is about presenting a property that buyers instantly connect with and ar...

How Outdoor Play Enhances Learning and Wellbeing

You don’t need to be an expert to conclude that play is an essential part of growing up. When children aren’t restricted and kept indoors, they de...

How to Build Passive Income Through Real Estate

Building passive income is one of the most effective ways to create long-term financial security. While there are many investment opportunities availa...

DIY Guide to Replacing Small Parts in Your Laundry Machine

Finding a puddle or a broken washer is frustrating, but you don’t always need a professional. Many common issues are caused by tiny parts that are c...

Best Practices for Managing Your Warehouse Partner Relationships

Your warehouse partner is an important part of your business. They sit in the middle of your promises to customers. Yet, when they deliver what’s pr...

Benefits of Solar-Based Water Circulation Systems

Imagine your water system running all day without touching your electricity bill. No noise, no heavy cables, no stress when prices go up. Fantastic, r...

Benefits of Using an Outrigger Crane for Complex Lifts

Complex lifts aren’t the kind of jobs you improvise. You’re dealing with awkward shapes, serious weight, and sites that never seem designed for wh...

A Beginner's Guide to Website Ranking

If you have a website, you probably want people to find it. But building a website alone does not guarantee visitors. Millions of websites compete for...

How to Prepare Your Home for Holiday Guests

Welcoming holiday guests into your home is one of life’s great pleasures. Whether it’s Christmas lunch, a long weekend reunion, or interstate re...

Colour Palettes That Work Beautifully for Christmas

Christmas styling has evolved well beyond the traditional red-and-green formula. While classic tones will always have their place, today’s festive...

Interior Decorating Mistakes to Avoid

Interior decorating has the power to completely transform how a home feels, functions and flows. Done well, it elevates everyday living and creates ...

How Chiropractic Can Help with Sciatica Treatment

Sciatica can be one of the most frustrating and disruptive forms of back pain. Characterised by pain that radiates from the lower back through the h...

Common Vulnerabilities Found During Australian Pen Tests

Penetration testing has become a critical component of modern cyber security strategy across Australia. From fast-growing SaaS startups to establish...